Wisconsin Supreme Court Election Results: Taylor Defeats Lazar

Few elections have reshaped a state supreme court’s ideological balance as decisively as Wisconsin’s April 7, 2026, contest. Preliminary results show state appeals court judge Chris Taylor defeating conservative rival Maria Lazar by roughly 20 percentage points — the largest margin in a contested Supreme Court race since 2000.

Election Date: April 7, 2026 ·
Seat: Replacement of Justice Rebecca Bradley (Conservative) ·
Candidates: Chris Taylor (Liberal) vs. Maria Lazar (Conservative) ·
Term Length: 10 years ·
Election Type: Nonpartisan ·
Votes Counted (as of Apr 9): >95%

Six key facts, one pattern: the 2026 race flipped the court’s balance decisively toward the liberal bloc, with Taylor outperforming not only his opponent but also prior liberal candidates by double-digit margins.

What were the results of the 2026 Wisconsin Supreme Court election?

Overall vote tally

• Chris Taylor (Liberal): approximately 60%
• Maria Lazar (Conservative): approximately 40%
• Margin: ~20 percentage points (Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference))

Taylor’s margin doubled that of the past three liberal victories in Supreme Court races, according to Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference). The victory also marked liberals’ fourth consecutive win for the court, per VoteHub (an election tracking platform).

The implication: Taylor built a coalition that transcended typical judicial-race turnout patterns.

Winner declaration status

Major outlets projected Taylor’s win on the evening of April 8, 2026, after counties including Dane and Milwaukee reported heavily liberal margins. As of April 9, more than 95% of votes had been counted, but official certification by the Wisconsin Elections Commission (the state’s official elections authority) is expected in late April.

The pattern is clear: Taylor’s victory was not only decisive but also broader than pre-election polling suggested — a sign that voter turnout and late-breaking issue salience favored the liberal candidate.

How did each county vote?

County-level results map

• An interactive county map is available via Wikimedia Commons (open-source media repository).
• Taylor won 84% in Dane County (YouTube – Caroline Dade (election analyst))
• Taylor flipped Ozaukee County (51%) and Marathon County (traditionally conservative) (YouTube – Caroline Dade)

Top counties by margin

Liberals were already expected to dominate in Dane and Milwaukee, but the upset came in counties that have been Republican strongholds. Taylor became the first Democratic-aligned candidate since 2015 to win a majority of Wisconsin counties (Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference)). He also won the 7th District (51.3%) and the 8th District (53.5%)(Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference)).

The pattern: Taylor’s coalition crossed urban boundaries and reached into conservative-leaning rural and suburban areas, reflecting a structural shift in judicial voting patterns.

Bottom line: Taylor’s win over Republican strongholds means Wisconsin judicial campaigns will now target suburban crossover voters, not just base counties.

Who were the candidates in the 2026 election?

Chris Taylor – background and platform

• State appeals court judge since 2019
• Endorsed by pro-choice and voting-rights groups
• Campaign focused on “fair courts, fair maps” (Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference))

Maria Lazar – background and platform

• State appeals court judge since 2021
• Supported by conservative legal organizations
• Emphasized “judicial restraint and originalism” (Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference))

Both candidates were state appeals court judges running to replace retiring conservative Justice Rebecca Bradley, whose seat had been held by the conservative bloc since 2016.

The trade-off: Taylor’s platform of “fair maps” resonated in a state still litigating gerrymandering, while Lazar’s message of restraint struggled to gain traction after the U.S. Supreme Court’s abortion ruling.

What did the polls say about the election?

Pre-election polling averages

• Polls showed a competitive race, with a narrow Taylor lead of 2–4 points (Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference))
• Taylor outperformed expectations by roughly 15 points (Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference))

Key issues driving voter sentiment

• Abortion rights: cited by Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference) as a top issue
• Redistricting: Taylor made “fair maps” a central promise
• Judicial independence: voters wary of partisan court capture

The gap between polling and actual results suggests that the same enthusiasm gap that lifted Democrats in 2023–2024 continued into 2026 for judicial races. The implication: traditional polling models may need recalibration for high-salience judicial contests.

What is the current composition of the Wisconsin Supreme Court?

List of current justices (as of April 2026)

• Chief Justice Annette Kingsland Ziegler (Conservative)
• Justice Rebecca Grassl Bradley (Conservative)
• Justice Brian Hagedorn (Conservative → often swing)
• Justice Jill Karofsky (Liberal)
• Justice Janet Protasiewicz (Liberal)
• Justice Ann Walsh Bradley (Liberal)
• Justice Chris Taylor (Liberal, incoming August 2026)

Ideological breakdown

Before the 2026 election, the court stood at 4 conservative–3 liberal. With Taylor replacing the retiring conservative Justice Rebecca Bradley, the balance shifts to 5 liberal–2 conservative (assuming Justice Hagedorn remains aligned with conservatives). This liberal majority is secure until at least August 2030 (Wikipedia (the crowd-sourced reference)).

The implication: for the next four years, Democrats have a reliable majority on a court that decides abortion access, redistricting maps, election laws, and corporate regulation.

Three candidates, one contrast: Taylor’s county sweep versus Lazar’s concentrated conservative base.

The catch: Taylor’s 84% in Dane County exceeded the prior liberal average by 9 points, while his 35% in Waukesha was a 5-point improvement — suggesting crossover appeal beyond the usual Democratic ceiling.

Expert perspectives

Two state appeals court judges, Chris Taylor and Maria Lazar, are running to replace retiring conservative Justice Rebecca Bradley.

CNN (major national news network)

Compared to previous court elections, this one has flown relatively under the radar in attention and spending.

The New York Times (a major national newspaper)

Judges serve ten-year terms, and to remain on the court, they must run for re-election after their term expires.

Ballotpedia (nonpartisan election reference)

For Wisconsin voters and political strategists, the 2026 election cements a liberal tilt that could last through the next decade. The decision for the conservative legal establishment is clear: rebuild a bench of candidates who can appeal beyond base counties, or accept that Wisconsin’s judicial elections are now dominated by nationalized issue battles.

Related reading: Howard County Judge Elkin Banned – Supreme Court Misconduct Ruling

Frequently asked questions